IMG_0750

Delivering the Shot

I recently changed my daily carry gun. No, not because it’s winter, and it is the season for bigger guns. I changed based on an experiment I did at the range a few weeks ago. I took a handful of guns with me that needed to be checked for various reasons – new mags for some, sight upgrade for another, and a caliber conversion in the last (for a friend).

IMG_0750

I ran some rounds through my G19 to test the new Trijicon HD’s I installed, then I tested the new mags I picked up for my Sig P238, M&P Shield and M&P Compact. Lastly I tested a .40 cal to 9mm conversion I did for a friend on their Glock G22.

After all the function tests were successful, I decided to shoot the guns at 7, 15, and 50 yards at a ¼ scale steel silhouette target. I decided to use a timer for a par time, but mostly I was listening for hits within the par time. I varied the times from 3 seconds to 9 seconds depending on the distance for each 5 to 10 shot string. I was drawing from appendix position with each pistol since that is how I have been carrying lately.

The results were interesting, and maybe I will post them in another entry, but I realized that hitting a ¼ scale target at 50 yards with a pocket size .380 is a challenge. I could do it, but not fast enough for my liking. The Shield made it a little easier, but I still wasn’t completely satisfied with the results. The M&P compact, my G19, and the converted G22 produced much better results for me. I could regularly hit 9 of 10 shots on the steel at 50 yards with those guns. The shorter distances were not a problem with these guns either…or the Shield for that matter.

What does all this mean? Well, for starters I need more practice with my P238 – at all distances. Those small guns are easy to carry, but they can be more difficult to shoot quickly and accurately. I don’t mean quickly or accurately, I mean shooting fast and getting good, solid hits. I would encourage everyone who routinely carries a smaller, pocket sized pistol as an EDC to really test themselves and see how they do. For instance, from 7 yards, can you draw your gun from where you normally carry it, and hit a paper plate six times in 3 seconds or less? Can you make a 25 yard head shot with it?

I learned I can, sometimes, but not consistently. I can do it consistently with the larger guns. Obviously, this makes sense, since the larger guns are easier to shoot. Because I carry a gun as a lifesaving tool in case of a worst case scenario, my ability to make hits needs to be automatic.

I had a discussion with someone the other day on this topic. They thought 25 and 50 yard hits were unreasonable. They cited the “3 shots, 3 yards, 3 seconds” statistic, and that in all likelihood a civilian encounter that required the use of a firearm would be at closer distances. Maybe. Maybe not. Who can know for sure anymore? I decided I’d rather be able to make hits at longer ranges, and have more shots with which to do it. So, I will continue to practice with the P238 for those times when that size pistol is all I can conceal because of the circumstances. However, my everyday gun now alternates between my M&P compact and my G19. I am not trying to tell you this is the answer for you…just sharing the results from my reality check.

Previous Post
The Great Handgun Caliber Debate
Concealed Carry News

The Great Caliber Debate Takes Another Twist…

Next Post
RH_SB_H715WC_XDSUB_1_29069__75947.1393292386.1280.1280
Concealed Carry News

Massad Ayood – 10 commandments of Concealed Carry

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *